Centerfield alternatives
Not everyone stays with Centerfield, and the reasons vary. It could be what the leads cost, or that they go to other buyers too, or a deposit, or a line Centerfield just does not sell. Each group below starts from one of those, and every company has a full review you can open.
Most similar to Centerfield
Start here. Each of these sells a mix of lines and lead types close to what you would be leaving behind at Centerfield.
QuoteWizard matches Centerfield on five of its six lines, adds renters and has nothing for commercial. QuoteWizard sells exclusive and shared leads, where Centerfield sells exclusive leads.
SmartFinancial matches Centerfield line for line and also has renters. Centerfield sells exclusive leads, while SmartFinancial sells exclusive and shared leads.
Line for line, Benepath and Centerfield match, auto, home and health included. Centerfield sells exclusive leads, while Benepath sells exclusive, shared and aged leads.
AWL has every line Centerfield sells, including auto, home and health, and then renters, annuity, disability, long-term care and business benefits on top. Centerfield sells exclusive leads, while AWL sells exclusive and shared leads.
If you want published prices
Want to see a price before you call? Centerfield won't show you one. These companies will.
For auto leads, QuoteWizard shows $3 to $26.75 per lead (as of October 2026).
For shared web leads, SmartFinancial shows $8 to $30 per lead (as of September 2026).
NextGen Leads skips auto, home and commercial, which Centerfield does sell. NextGen Leads sells exclusive and shared leads, where Centerfield sells exclusive leads. NextGen Leads lists exclusive health data leads from $4 per lead (as of October 2026).
Caboom Leads matches Centerfield on five of its six lines, adds final expense, annuity and IUL and has nothing for commercial. Caboom Leads sells exclusive and aged leads, where Centerfield sells exclusive leads. Caboom Leads lists life leads at $35 per lead (as of October 2026).
If you don't want a deposit
You put money in first at Centerfield. These companies sell by the order, with no deposit and no prepaid balance.
Financialize has life like Centerfield, plus final expense and annuity. What Financialize lacks is auto, home, health, Medicare and commercial. Financialize asks for no deposit and sells by the order.
Of the six lines Centerfield sells, LeadMaker has five, with auto, home and health among them. LeadMaker also sells renters and mortgage protection and leaves out commercial. LeadMaker takes no deposit.
AWL asks for no deposit and sells by the order.
Caboom Leads has no deposit.
If you want aged leads
Centerfield doesn't sell aged leads. These companies do, in at least one of the same lines.
Benepath has no published price for commercial (business owners, workers' comp, commercial auto, property and casualty).
LeadMaker prices aged insurance leads at $275 to $1,000 per pack (as of October 2026).
iLeads skips Medicare and commercial, which Centerfield does sell. iLeads doesn't post a price for aged web leads.
Caboom Leads lists aged final expense and Medicare leads at $0.75 to $15 per lead (as of October 2026).
If you sell other lines too
Centerfield has no final expense or annuity leads. The companies below do, and they also overlap with the lines Centerfield sells.
Financialize adds final expense and annuity.
Of the six lines Centerfield sells, Lead Connections has two: Medicare and life. Lead Connections also sells final expense, annuity, cancer, long term care and veterans and leaves out auto, home, health and commercial.
Lead Concepts matches Centerfield on one of its six lines, adds final expense, annuity and mortgage protection and has nothing for auto, home, health, life or commercial. Lead Concepts sells exclusive and shared leads, where Centerfield sells exclusive leads.
For final expense and annuity, Caboom Leads is an option.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best alternative to Centerfield?
Start with SmartFinancial and QuoteWizard, since they sell about what Centerfield does in lines and lead types. Then buy a few leads from two or three companies and see what each sale costs you, which tells you more than any list.
How do I compare Centerfield with its alternatives?
Four things separate Centerfield from the rest: lines and lead types, shared or exclusive, how you get started and what happens to a bad lead. Each review linked above takes them one at a time.
How we chose
Every company listed sells at least one of the same lines as Centerfield. Inside each group the order follows how closely lines and lead types match, taken from their published product pages. Read the Centerfield review or compare every company on the lead companies page.
How we researched this. We based this page on each company's published pricing where available, terms and product pages, reviewed in October 2026, together with our team's experience working with insurance agents and agency owners since 2008.