Tivly alternatives
Why drop Tivly? Maybe the price, maybe the sharing, maybe the terms or the lines. Start from the reason that fits you below and open the review of any company that looks worth a call.
Most similar to Tivly
The closest matches come first, going by the lines and lead types each company sells.
Besides health and commercial, which Tivly also sells, SmartFinancial has auto, home, renters, Medicare and life. SmartFinancial sells exclusive and shared leads, where Tivly sells exclusive leads.
Benepath matches Tivly line for line and also has auto, home, Medicare and life. Tivly sells exclusive leads, while Benepath sells exclusive, shared and aged leads.
Centerfield sells health and commercial like Tivly, plus auto, home, Medicare and life.
AWL has both of the lines Tivly sells and adds auto, home, renters, Medicare, life and four other lines. Tivly sells exclusive leads, while AWL sells exclusive and shared leads.
If you want published prices
Tivly has no posted prices. These companies do, each on its own website.
For shared web leads, SmartFinancial shows $8 to $30 per lead (as of September 2026).
Compared with Tivly, NextGen Leads adds Medicare and life. NextGen Leads has no commercial, and the other line is the same.
Tivly sells exclusive leads, while NextGen Leads sells exclusive and shared leads. For exclusive health data leads, NextGen Leads shows from $4 per lead (as of October 2026).
Of the two lines Tivly sells, Caboom Leads has one: health. Caboom Leads also sells auto, home, Medicare, life, final expense and two other lines and leaves out commercial.
Tivly sells exclusive leads, while Caboom Leads sells exclusive and aged leads. For ACA health leads, Caboom Leads shows $27 per lead (as of October 2026).
G.O.A.T. Leads matches Tivly on one of its two lines, adds life, final expense, mortgage protection, IUL and trucker and has nothing for commercial. G.O.A.T. Leads sells exclusive and aged leads, where Tivly sells exclusive leads. G.O.A.T. Leads lists under-65 health leads at $22 to $25 per lead (as of October 2026).
If you want live transfers
Tivly doesn't sell live transfers. These companies do, in at least one of the same lines.
For live call transfers, SmartFinancial shows $18 to $70 per call (as of September 2026).
NextGen Leads lists health live transfers from $35 per call (as of October 2026).
Centerfield doesn't post a price for exclusive insurance live transfers.
AWL doesn't post a price for qualified Concierge Calls (live transfers).
If you want aged leads
Looking for aged leads? Tivly has none. These companies do, and the lines overlap with what it sells.
Benepath doesn't post a price for commercial (business owners, workers' comp, commercial auto, property and casualty).
iLeads has health like Tivly, plus auto, home and life. What iLeads lacks is commercial. iLeads doesn't post a price for aged web leads.
For aged home, auto and health leads, Caboom Leads shows $0.75 to $16 per lead (as of October 2026).
G.O.A.T. Leads prices aged health leads from $6 per lead (as of October 2026).
If you sell other lines too
Tivly doesn't sell auto, home, life, Medicare, final expense or annuity leads. These companies sell more of them.
Benepath also sells auto, home, life and Medicare.
Centerfield can fill the gap on auto, home, life and Medicare.
AWL also sells auto, home, life, Medicare and annuity.
Caboom Leads sells every line Tivly is missing.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best alternative to Tivly?
Start with Benepath and Centerfield, which match Tivly most closely on lines and lead types, then place small orders with two or three companies and compare cost per sale.
How do I compare Tivly with its alternatives?
Four things separate Tivly from the rest: lines and lead types, shared or exclusive, how you get started and what happens to a bad lead. Each review linked above takes them one at a time.
How we chose
Every company listed sells at least one of the same lines as Tivly. Inside each group the order follows how closely lines and lead types match, taken from their published product pages. Read the Tivly review or compare every company on the lead companies page.
How we researched this. We based this page on each company's published pricing where available, terms and product pages, reviewed in October 2026, together with our team's experience working with insurance agents and agency owners since 2008.