Evergreen Agency Talent review: services, fees and terms
Evergreen Agency Talent recruits producers and CSRs for local P&C agencies on a monthly subscription instead of a fee per hire. It posts your jobs, screens applicants and books interviews, with the CareerPlug applicant tracking system included.
It costs $397 a month for a six-month first term. Once you join, no competing agent can sign up in your ZIP code.
- Best for
- Captive and independent P&C agencies that hire producers and CSRs often
- Type
- Monthly subscription recruiting
- Roles
- Producers and CSRs
- Lines
- P&C
- Fee
- $397 a month for a six-month first term, then month to month
- Agency types
- Independent and captive agencies
Our take
Evergreen Agency Talent suits a captive or independent P&C agency that hires producers and CSRs often and wants a set monthly cost instead of a fee on each hire. It runs your job posts through CareerPlug, screens applicants and books interviews.
The first term is six months and is owed in full if you cancel early. An agency filling one seat should compare the $2,382 first term with a quote for a single search.
Pros
- Published $397 a month with no fee per hire
- CareerPlug applicant tracking included
- No competing agent can join in your ZIP code
- Built for producer and CSR hiring
Cons
- Six-month first term owed in full on early exit
- The signer personally guarantees payment
- No published placement guarantee
- Recruits producers and CSRs only
Roles, lines and region
- Roles
- Producers and CSRs
- Lines
- P&C
- Agency types
- Independent agencies and captive agents, including Allstate, American Family, Country Financial and Farm Bureau of Michigan
- Where
- Agencies in the US
How they work
Subscription recruiting
You pay a flat monthly fee and Evergreen keeps recruiting for you. There's no fee when you hire.
ZIP-code exclusivity
Once you join, Evergreen won't sign up a competing agent in your ZIP code.
Fees and when you pay
| Item | Fee | Paid when |
|---|---|---|
| Recruiting subscription | $397 a month | At signing, then the same day each month |
| First six months | $2,382 in all | Owed in full even if you cancel early |
Price as of October 2026, from Evergreen's service agreement. Paid by credit or debit card. No fee when you hire.
Guarantee
Ask for the replacement guarantee in writing before you sign. Evergreen publishes no placement guarantee. The subscription keeps recruiting while you stay enrolled, but that covers no single hire.
Finding and screening candidates
- Where candidates come from
- Job boards through your CareerPlug account, plus its insurance careers page
- Interviews
- Pre-screens applicants, reviews their backgrounds and books your interviews
- Applicant tracking
- CareerPlug included
Exclusivity and privacy
- Your ZIP code
- No competing agent can join Evergreen in your ZIP code
- Other recruiters
- Allowed. The agreement doesn't require you to use only Evergreen
- Publicity
- Evergreen may name you as a client, including on social media
Contract terms
- Term
- Six months, then month to month
- Cancellation
- Signed written notice on your letterhead at least 30 days before the current term ends. After month six each term is one month
- Early exit
- The rest of the first six months is billed in full
- Personal guaranty
- The person who signs for the agency is personally liable for payment
- Governing law
- Michigan, with disputes in Ingham County
From Evergreen's service agreement, checked October 2026.
Evergreen Agency Talent alternatives
- EZ Recruiting & Consulting$3,000 per hirePay per hire, with a 60-day replacement search
- Your Recruiting DepartmentQuote onlyAssessments and license checks for independent agencies
- Capstone Search GroupQuote onlyPay only when you hire, with temps if needed
- MarshBerry Talent SearchQuote onlyTies producer hiring to a pay plan
See every option in insurance recruiting firms.
Frequently asked questions
How much does Evergreen Agency Talent cost?
$397 a month for a six-month first term, then month to month. There is no fee when you hire.
Can I cancel Evergreen early?
Cancelling in the first six months makes the rest of that term due. After that, give written notice at least 30 days before the current monthly term ends.
What is ZIP-code exclusivity?
Once you join, Evergreen won't enroll a competing agent in your ZIP code.
What if a new hire quits?
The subscription keeps recruiting while you stay enrolled.
Does Evergreen include an applicant tracking system?
Yes. CareerPlug is included.
How we researched this review. We based this review on the pricing, terms and product pages published by Evergreen Agency Talent, reviewed in October 2026, together with our team's experience working with insurance agents and agency owners since 2008.
Corrections
Vendors change their pricing all the time and they don't email us when they do. So if you see a price on here that's gone up, a plan Evergreen Agency Talent quit selling or a contract term that reads different now, let us know and send the link to the page where Evergreen Agency Talent has it. Somebody here pulls up that page and checks it before we change anything on ours.